Results Audit

Verify claims before prose changes. Produce a claim-status verdict and evidence trail, not just a narrative opinion.

Audit Checklist

• Identify whether the optimization space is constrained or unconstrained.
• Identify whether the claim relies on single-objective runs or a true multi-objective method.
• Identify whether the evidence comes from one run, repeated seeds, deterministic comparisons, or fixed-policy seed checks.
• Verify metric definitions, scales, units, and comparability.
• Verify whether the reported allocation pattern is observed from results or imposed by bounds.
• Verify whether the current manuscript wording matches the latest code and outputs.

Procedure

1. Locate the manuscript claim or reviewer concern.
2. Trace it to the relevant code path and result files.
3. Classify the claim as:
   • supported
   • needs revision
   • unsupported
4. Record the evidence files needed for the tracker.
5. Propose exact wording replacements when the claim needs revision.