Human-in-the-Loop Zitatverwaltung. Kein Paper wird zitiert ohne explizite menschliche Freigabe. Verwaltet BibLaTeX und den Genehmigungsworkflow.
This skill is the single authority over the thesis bibliography. No paper enters references.bib without explicit human approval. No \cite{} command references a paper that has not passed through this gatekeeper. It enforces a strict human-in-the-loop workflow for all citations, ensuring the thesis only references papers the author has actually read and deliberately chosen to include.
Nothing is cited without the human saying YES.
This is non-negotiable. No other skill, no automation, no convenience shortcut can bypass this rule. The human (thesis author) must explicitly approve every single paper before it can appear in the bibliography or be referenced in any .tex file.
The gatekeeper reads from , which is populated by the research-scout skill. Each entry has a status of , , , or .
thesis/latex/bibliography/pending-papers.jsonpendingapprovedrejectedduplicatePapers are presented for review, either one at a time or in batches:
Single Review Format:
--- Paper Review ---
Title: Communicative Agents for Software Development
Authors: Chen Qian, Xin Cong, Wei Liu et al.
Year: 2024
Venue: ACL 2024
URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07924
Summary: Proposes ChatDev, a multi-agent framework where LLM agents
collaborate through role-based chat to develop software.
Relevance Score: 4/5
Suggested for: 03-verwandte-arbeiten (Bestehende Multi-Agenten-Frameworks)
Decision: [YES / NO / LATER]
If YES: Suggested BibTeX key: qian2024chatdev
Notes? (optional)
If NO: Reason? (brief)
Batch Review Format:
--- Batch Review (5 papers) ---
1. [Score 5] "AutoGen: Enabling Next-Gen LLM Applications"
Wu et al., 2024, arXiv → 03-verwandte-arbeiten
Decision: ___
2. [Score 4] "Toolformer: Language Models Can Teach Themselves to Use Tools"
Schick et al., 2023, NeurIPS → 02-grundlagen
Decision: ___
3. [Score 4] "ReAct: Synergizing Reasoning and Acting in Language Models"
Yao et al., 2023, ICLR → 02-grundlagen
Decision: ___
4. [Score 3] "A Survey on Large Language Model based Autonomous Agents"
Wang et al., 2024, Frontiers of CS → 03-verwandte-arbeiten
Decision: ___
5. [Score 3] "MetaGPT: Meta Programming for Multi-Agent Collaboration"
Hong et al., 2024, ICLR → 03-verwandte-arbeiten
Decision: ___
For each paper, the human chooses one of three options:
pending-papers.json to approved-papers.jsonreferences.bibpending-papers.json is updated to approvedapproved_date is recordedpending-papers.json is updated to rejectedrejection_reason field is added (provided by human or prompted)pending-papers.json (audit trail)pending-papers.json with status pendingthesis/latex/bibliography/pending-papers.jsonthesis/latex/bibliography/approved-papers.json[
{
"id": "sem-scholar-abc123",
"bibtex_key": "qian2024chatdev",
"title": "Communicative Agents for Software Development",
"authors": ["Chen Qian", "Xin Cong", "Wei Liu"],
"year": 2024,
"venue": "ACL 2024",
"approved_date": "2026-02-22",
"approved_for_chapters": ["03-verwandte-arbeiten"],
"notes": "Good comparison to our approach. They use role-based chat, we use tool-calling orchestration.",
"url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07924"
}
]
thesis/latex/bibliography/references.bib@inproceedings{qian2024chatdev,
author = {Qian, Chen and Cong, Xin and Liu, Wei and others},
title = {Communicative Agents for Software Development},
booktitle = {Proceedings of the 62nd Annual Meeting of the Association
for Computational Linguistics (ACL)},
year = {2024},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07924},
doi = {10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.1},
}
@article{schick2023toolformer,
author = {Schick, Timo and Dwivedi-Yu, Jane and Dess{\`i}, Roberto
and others},
title = {Toolformer: Language Models Can Teach Themselves to Use Tools},
journal = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS)},
year = {2023},
volume = {36},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04761},
}
@article, @inproceedings, @book, @thesis, @online, @report{\"u} for ue, {\"a} for ae, {\"o} for oe, {\ss} for ssand to separate authors, with and others for long author listsdoi when availableurl always[firstauthor_lastname][year][keyword] (e.g., qian2024chatdev)langid = {german} fieldShow all \cite{} commands in a given chapter and their approval status:
--- Citation Audit: 04-konzept ---
\cite{qian2024chatdev} → APPROVED (2026-02-22)
\cite{wu2024autogen} → APPROVED (2026-02-20)
\cite{TODO:mcp-spec} → TODO PLACEHOLDER (needs real paper)
\cite{smith2023agents} → NOT FOUND in approved list!
Detect \cite{} commands in .tex files that reference keys not present in references.bib:
--- Orphan Citations Found ---
04-konzept.tex:42 \cite{smith2023agents} → Key not in references.bib
05-impl.tex:118 \cite{jones2024mcp} → Key not in references.bib
Action: These must either be approved through the gatekeeper or removed.
Detect papers in approved-papers.json / references.bib that are never cited in any .tex file:
--- Unused Approved Papers ---
mueller2024survey "A Survey on Agent Architectures"
Approved: 2026-02-15
Approved for: 03-verwandte-arbeiten
Cited in: NOWHERE
Action: Either cite in an appropriate section or consider removing from bibliography.
Scan all .tex files for \cite{TODO:*} placeholders:
--- TODO Citations ---
02-grundlagen.tex:28 \cite{TODO:mas-history}
Context: "Multi-Agenten-Systeme wurden erstmals formalisiert"
Need: Foundational MAS paper (Wooldridge, Jennings era)
04-konzept.tex:95 \cite{TODO:mcp-specification}
Context: "Das MCP definiert einen standardisierten Kanal"
Need: Official MCP specification or announcement
Total: 7 TODO citations remaining
| Skill | Interaction |
|---|---|
| research-scout | Writes to pending-papers.json; gatekeeper reads and processes |
| draft-writer | Uses \cite{TODO:topic} placeholders; gatekeeper resolves them |
| thesis-structure | Provides chapter IDs for approved_for_chapters mapping |
| code-to-thesis | No direct interaction (code references are not citations) |
approved_date is always recorded.tex files, it must not change