Youtube Rag Storage

Manual Invocation

# Ingest a single video
python scripts/rag/ingest_video.py https://youtu.be/VIDEO_ID

# Search across all ingested content
python scripts/rag/semantic_search.py "RAG implementation best practices"

# Search within specific video
python scripts/rag/semantic_search.py "vector database" --video-id VIDEO_ID

Core Capabilities

1. Video Ingestion Pipeline

Complete workflow from URL to searchable content:

YouTube URL
    ↓
[Download + Transcribe] (youtube-video-analysis)
    ↓
[Intelligent Chunking] (dockling_chunker)
    ↓
[Generate Embeddings] (OpenAI API)
    ↓
[Store in Supabase] (db_client)
    ↓
Searchable Vector Database

Features:

• Automatic video metadata extraction
• Transcript-aware chunking (preserves code blocks, headings)
• Batch embedding generation (efficient API usage)
• Atomic database transactions
• Progress tracking and error recovery
• Cost estimation and tracking

2. Embedding Generation

OpenAI text-embedding-3-small specifications:

• Dimensions: 1536
• Cost: $0.020 per 1M tokens
• Performance: ~130 tokens per chunk average
• Quality: State-of-the-art semantic similarity

Batch processing:

• Processes up to 2048 texts per API request
• Automatic retry logic for transient failures
• Token counting and cost estimation
• Progress indicators for large batches

3. Semantic Search

Vector similarity using cosine distance:

# Search by natural language query
results = semantic_search(
    query="How to implement RAG with Claude",
    limit=10,
    min_similarity=0.7
)

# Filter by video or chunk type
results = semantic_search(
    query="Python code examples",
    video_id="dQw4w9WgXcQ",
    chunk_type="code",
    limit=5
)

Search capabilities:

• Semantic similarity (not just keyword matching)
• Filter by video, author, chunk type, date range
• Minimum similarity threshold
• Ranked results with similarity scores
• Includes context (timestamps, video metadata)

4. Multi-Modal Content Support

Handles diverse content types:

• Transcript chunks: Regular spoken content
• Code blocks: Programming examples preserved with syntax
• Diagrams: Visual content descriptions (when available)
• Mixed content: Combined text + code sections

Metadata preserved:

• Video title, author, duration, views
• Chunk timestamps (when in video)
• Word/character counts
• Structural information (headings, lists)
• Custom metadata (tags, notes)

Workflow Examples

Example 1: Ingest Tutorial Video

User: "Ingest this FastAPI tutorial into the knowledge base: https://youtu.be/example"

Skill Actions:

1. Download video and transcribe (uses youtube-video-analysis)
2. Chunk transcript with Dockling (preserves code blocks)
3. Generate embeddings for each chunk (OpenAI API)
4. Store in Supabase with full metadata
5. Report ingestion stats (chunks, cost, time)

Output:

================================================================================
YouTube RAG Ingestion Pipeline
================================================================================

STEP 1: Download & Transcribe
[OK] Downloaded: FastAPI Complete Tutorial by TechWithTim
[OK] Duration: 45:30 (2730 seconds)
[OK] Transcribed: 18,500 characters

STEP 2: Intelligent Chunking
[OK] Created 48 chunks using Dockling
     - 32 transcript chunks
     - 12 code chunks
     - 4 heading chunks

STEP 3: Generate Embeddings
[OK] Generated 48 embeddings (1536 dimensions each)
     - Processed: 6,240 tokens
     - Cost: $0.00012

STEP 4: Store in Database
[OK] Inserted video metadata
[OK] Stored 48 chunks with embeddings
     - Video UUID: a1b2c3d4-e5f6-7890-abcd-ef1234567890

================================================================================
INGESTION COMPLETE
================================================================================

Video ID: dQw4w9WgXcQ
Chunks stored: 48
Total cost: $0.00012
Processing time: 2m 15s
Ready for semantic search!

Example 2: Semantic Search

User: "Search my knowledge base for: implementing RAG with vector databases"

Skill Actions:

1. Generate query embedding (OpenAI API)
2. Search Supabase using vector similarity
3. Retrieve top K most relevant chunks
4. Format results with context

Output:

📺 Search Results for: "implementing RAG with vector databases"

================================================================================

1. Building Production RAG Systems by AI Jason (0.892 similarity)
   Timestamp: 12:45
   Type: transcript
   "When implementing RAG, you need three core components: a vector database
   like Supabase with pgvector, an embedding model like OpenAI's
   text-embedding-3-small, and a chunking strategy that preserves context..."

2. Vector Databases Explained by Coding with Cole (0.874 similarity)
   Timestamp: 08:20
   Type: code
   ```python
   def semantic_search(query: str, limit: int = 10):
       # Generate query embedding
       embedding = openai.Embedding.create(
           model="text-embedding-3-small",
           input=query
       )
       # Search database with cosine similarity
       results = db.query(embedding, limit=limit)
       return results

3. RAG Tutorial: From Zero to Production by Tech Lead (0.856 similarity) Timestamp: 25:10 Type: transcript "The key insight is that vector databases use approximate nearest neighbor search algorithms like IVFFlat or HNSW to find similar embeddings quickly. For a dataset of 100K chunks, search takes under 100ms..."

[7 more results...]

Total results: 10 Search time: 87ms

### Example 3: Multi-Video Research

**User**: "Find all mentions of 'Claude API integration' across my entire knowledge base"

**Skill Actions**:
1. Search across all stored videos
2. Group results by video
3. Show relevant sections with timestamps

**Output**:

📺 Found mentions in 4 videos:

Video 1: "Claude API Tutorial" by Anthropic Docs (3 mentions)

• 05:30: Setting up authentication with API keys
• 12:45: Streaming responses with Claude 3.5 Sonnet
• 28:10: Error handling and retry logic

Video 2: "Building AI Agents" by AI Engineer (2 mentions)

• 18:20: Integrating Claude into agent workflows
• 35:50: Tool use and function calling with Claude

Video 3: "FastAPI + Claude" by Python Tutorial (2 mentions)

• 09:15: Creating API endpoints for Claude integration
• 22:40: Async request handling

Video 4: "Production AI Apps" by Tech With Tim (1 mention)

• 41:05: Deploying Claude-powered applications

## Integration with Existing Systems

### YouTube Video Analysis Skill
```python
from youtube_video_analysis import download_video, extract_audio, transcribe_audio

# Reuse existing functionality
video_path, metadata = download_video(url, output_dir)
audio_path = extract_audio(video_path, output_dir)
transcript = transcribe_audio(audio_path, model_size='base')

Dockling Chunker

from dockling_chunker import chunk_transcript_with_dockling

# Intelligent structure-aware chunking
chunks = chunk_transcript_with_dockling(
    transcript=transcript,
    video_metadata=metadata,
    min_chunk_size=400,
    max_chunk_size=1000,
    overlap_tokens=50
)

Supabase Database Client

from db_client import SupabaseClient

client = SupabaseClient()
video_uuid = client.insert_video(video_data)
client.insert_chunks(video_uuid, chunks)
results = client.semantic_search(query_embedding, limit=10)
client.close()

OpenAI Embeddings

from openai import OpenAI

client = OpenAI(api_key=os.getenv('OPENAI_API_KEY'))
response = client.embeddings.create(
    model="text-embedding-3-small",
    input=texts
)
embeddings = [e.embedding for e in response.data]

Technical Specifications

Embedding Model

• Model: text-embedding-3-small
• Dimensions: 1536
• Context Window: 8192 tokens
• Pricing: $0.020 per 1M tokens
• Performance: 300K+ tokens per minute

Database Schema

-- Video metadata
CREATE TABLE youtube_videos (
    id UUID PRIMARY KEY DEFAULT gen_random_uuid(),
    video_id TEXT UNIQUE NOT NULL,
    url TEXT NOT NULL,
    title TEXT NOT NULL,
    author TEXT,
    duration_seconds INTEGER,
    views BIGINT,
    description TEXT,
    transcript_full TEXT,
    visual_analysis JSONB,
    metadata JSONB,
    processed_at TIMESTAMP,
    created_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW(),
    updated_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW()
);

-- Transcript chunks with embeddings
CREATE TABLE transcript_chunks (
    id UUID PRIMARY KEY DEFAULT gen_random_uuid(),
    video_id UUID REFERENCES youtube_videos(id) ON DELETE CASCADE,
    chunk_text TEXT NOT NULL,
    chunk_index INTEGER NOT NULL,
    chunk_type TEXT NOT NULL,
    timestamp_start NUMERIC,
    timestamp_end NUMERIC,
    embedding vector(1536) NOT NULL,
    word_count INTEGER,
    char_count INTEGER,
    has_code BOOLEAN DEFAULT FALSE,
    has_diagram BOOLEAN DEFAULT FALSE,
    metadata JSONB,
    created_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW(),
    UNIQUE(video_id, chunk_index)
);

-- Vector similarity index (IVFFlat)
CREATE INDEX idx_chunks_embedding ON transcript_chunks
USING ivfflat (embedding vector_cosine_ops)
WITH (lists = 100);

Performance Characteristics

Ingestion Performance (1-hour video):

• Download: ~30 seconds (depends on network)
• Transcription: ~90 seconds (base model, CPU)
• Chunking: <1 second
• Embedding generation: ~5 seconds
• Database storage: ~2 seconds
• Total: ~2-3 minutes

Search Performance:

• Query embedding generation: ~200ms
• Vector search (100K chunks): <100ms
• Result formatting: <10ms
• Total query time: ~300ms

Storage Requirements (per 1-hour video):

• Video metadata: ~10KB
• Full transcript: ~100KB
• Chunks (avg 500): 500 × 500 bytes = 250KB
• Embeddings (500 × 1536 × 4 bytes): 3.07MB
• Total per video: ~3.4MB

Cost Analysis

OpenAI Embeddings (per video):

1-hour video:
- Transcript: ~30K words = 40K tokens
- Chunked into: ~500 chunks
- Embedding tokens: 500 chunks × 130 tokens avg = 65K tokens
- Cost: 65K × $0.020 / 1M = $0.0013

3-hour video:
- Embedding tokens: ~195K tokens
- Cost: $0.0039

Cost per video: ~$0.001 to $0.004 (essentially FREE!)

Supabase Storage:

Free Tier: 500MB database storage
- ~147 videos at 3.4MB each
- Sufficient for prototyping and small-scale use

Pro Tier: $25/month for 8GB
- ~2,400 videos
- Production-ready scale

Total Cost (100 videos):

• Embeddings: 100 × $0.002 = $0.20
• Storage: $0 (free tier)
• Total: ~$0.20

Usage Instructions

Setup (One-time)

1. Install Dependencies:

pip install openai psycopg2-binary pgvector python-dotenv

2. Configure Environment:

# .env file
OPENAI_API_KEY=sk-your-openai-api-key
SUPABASE_HOST=db.xxxxxxxxxxxx.supabase.co
SUPABASE_PASSWORD=your-supabase-password

3. Verify Setup:

python scripts/db/test_connection.py

Ingest Videos

Single video:

python scripts/rag/ingest_video.py https://youtu.be/VIDEO_ID

Multiple videos:

# Create a list of URLs
echo "https://youtu.be/VIDEO1" >> videos.txt
echo "https://youtu.be/VIDEO2" >> videos.txt

# Batch ingest
for url in $(cat videos.txt); do
    python scripts/rag/ingest_video.py "$url"
done

With custom settings:

python scripts/rag/ingest_video.py \
    https://youtu.be/VIDEO_ID \
    --output-dir ./data/youtube \
    --model-size small \
    --min-chunk-size 400 \
    --max-chunk-size 1000

Search Content

Basic search:

python scripts/rag/semantic_search.py "RAG implementation with Claude"

Advanced search:

# Search with filters
python scripts/rag/semantic_search.py \
    "Python code examples" \
    --limit 20 \
    --min-similarity 0.7 \
    --chunk-type code

# Search within specific video
python scripts/rag/semantic_search.py \
    "vector database setup" \
    --video-id dQw4w9WgXcQ \
    --limit 5

Programmatic usage:

from scripts.rag.semantic_search import search_youtube_content

results = search_youtube_content(
    query="How to implement RAG",
    limit=10,
    min_similarity=0.7,
    video_id=None  # Search all videos
)

for result in results:
    print(f"Video: {result['title']}")
    print(f"Similarity: {result['similarity']:.3f}")
    print(f"Text: {result['chunk_text'][:200]}...")

Best Practices

Video Selection

• ✅ Choose high-quality educational content
• ✅ Prefer structured tutorials and technical videos
• ✅ Ensure clear audio for accurate transcription
• ❌ Avoid music videos or entertainment content
• ❌ Skip videos with poor audio quality

Chunking Strategy

• Default settings work well for most content
• Increase max_chunk_size for longer, detailed explanations
• Decrease min_chunk_size for short, dense content
• Use overlap_tokens to maintain context between chunks

Embedding Quality

• Text-embedding-3-small is optimal for cost/performance
• Chunk size affects semantic coherence (400-1000 words ideal)
• Include video metadata in search context for better relevance

Search Optimization

• Use specific queries for better results
• Adjust min_similarity threshold (0.7 is good default)
• Filter by chunk_type for code vs text searches
• Combine semantic search with metadata filters (author, date)

Cost Management

• Embeddings are cheap (~$0.002 per video)
• Main cost is Supabase storage at scale
• Cache embeddings to avoid regeneration
• Use free tier (500MB) for prototyping

Limitations

Current Limitations

• Visual content: Only transcripts, no frame analysis (yet)
• Timestamps: Chunk-level only (no word-level alignment)
• Languages: Best results with English content
• Real-time: Must download and process first (no streaming)
• Authentication: Public videos only (no private content)

Performance Constraints

• Large videos (>3 hours) may need chunking optimization
• Search performance degrades beyond 1M chunks (add sharding)
• Embedding generation limited by OpenAI API rate limits
• Database connection pool may need tuning for high concurrency

Troubleshooting

Common Issues

Issue: "OpenAI API key not found"

# Solution: Set environment variable
export OPENAI_API_KEY=sk-your-api-key-here
# Or add to .env file

Issue: "Database connection failed"

# Solution: Check Supabase credentials
python scripts/db/test_connection.py

Issue: "Embedding dimension mismatch"

# Solution: Ensure using text-embedding-3-small (1536 dimensions)
# Check model name in generate_embeddings.py

Issue: "Out of memory during embedding generation"

# Solution: Reduce batch size
# In generate_embeddings.py, change batch_size from 2048 to 100

Issue: "Search returns no results"

# Solution: Lower similarity threshold
python scripts/rag/semantic_search.py "query" --min-similarity 0.5

Future Enhancements

Planned Features (Task 044 Roadmap)

• Multi-modal analysis: Extract code from video frames (Task 044-1)
• Smart frame selection: Detect code/diagram screenshots (Task 044-2)
• Voice input: Search with spoken queries (Task 044-7)
• Batch processing: Ingest entire playlists efficiently (Task 044-8)
• Progress indicators: Real-time status updates (Task 044-9)
• SubAgent integration: Complex multi-video research (Task 044-10)
• MCP server: Expose to Claude Desktop (Task 044-11)

Potential Improvements

• Automatic chapter detection and segmentation
• Speaker diarization (who said what)
• Multi-language support with translation
• Real-time streaming ingestion
• Automatic tag generation
• Content recommendation engine
• Duplicate detection across videos
• Incremental updates (only new content)

Reference Documentation

• Embedding Guide: Deep dive into OpenAI embeddings
• Semantic Search Guide: Vector similarity techniques
• Database Schema: Complete schema documentation
• Supabase Setup: Database setup instructions

Examples

• Ingestion Workflow: Step-by-step ingestion example
• Search Examples: Various search patterns
• Cost Analysis: Detailed cost breakdown

Scripts

• ingest_video.py: Main ingestion pipeline
• generate_embeddings.py: Embedding generation
• semantic_search.py: Search interface

Version: 1.0.0 Created: 2025-10-28 Status: Production Ready Task: 044-6 Dependencies: youtube-video-analysis, dockling_chunker, db_client, openai