Name: Review Paper
Author: naj2r

Manuscript Review

Produce a thorough, constructive review — the kind a top-journal referee would write.

Input: $ARGUMENTS — path to a paper (.tex, .pdf, .qmd), or a section name (e.g., "introduction", "results").

For This Paper

The paper is at: $OL/ Key sections: $OL/Sections/1-introduction.tex through $OL/Sections/6-conclusion.tex Results reference: $RB/output/results/regression_results.csv

Review Dimensions

1. Argument Structure

Research question clearly stated?
Introduction motivates effectively?
Logical flow: question → method → results → conclusion?
Conclusions supported by evidence?

Review Paper

Manuscript Review

For This Paper

Review Dimensions

1. Argument Structure

2. Identification Strategy

Review Paper

Manuscript Review

For This Paper

Review Dimensions

1. Argument Structure

2. Identification Strategy

3. Econometric Specification

4. Literature Positioning

5. Writing Quality & Presentation

Output

Goplaces

Research Ops

Editor

Fact Checker

Deep Research

Academic Researcher