Systematically evaluate scientific manuscripts for methodology, statistics, reproducibility, and scholarly rigor. Provides structured feedback following peer review best practices.
Guide thorough, constructive evaluation of scientific manuscripts across disciplines. This skill provides a structured framework for assessing methodology, statistics, reproducibility, ethics, and presentation quality.
Organize comments hierarchically:
Overall assessment (2-3 sentences)
Fundamental issues affecting validity or conclusions
Improvements that would strengthen the work
Clarifications needed to complete review
Adjust focus based on field:
Coordinates with:
academic-writing for understanding manuscript standardsreference-management for citation verificationlit-review for assessing literature coverage