Thesis Tracker

Chapter Statuses

Each chapter progresses through five stages:

leer (Empty)

• The .tex file either does not exist or contains only the chapter heading and section stubs
• No substantive content has been written
• Word count: 0 or near 0

notizen (Notes)

• Outline exists with bullet points, key phrases, or rough notes
• Structure is visible but prose is not written
• May contain TODO markers and placeholder text
• Word count: typically under 30% of target

entwurf (Draft)

• First complete draft of the chapter
• All sections have prose, though it may be rough
• Citations may be incomplete (TODO markers for missing sources)
• Word count: 60-100% of target

ueberarbeitet (Revised)

• Draft has been reviewed and revised
• Argument-advisor feedback has been addressed
• Citations are complete or nearly complete
• Language has been polished
• Word count: 90-110% of target

final (Final)

• Ready for submission
• No TODO markers remaining
• All citations resolved
• All figures present and referenced
• Spell-checked and grammar-checked
• Word count: within 10% of target

Tracking Capabilities

Word Count per Chapter

Uses texcount to parse .tex files and count words accurately, excluding LaTeX commands, comments, and environments like minted or lstlisting.

# Count words in a specific chapter
texcount -inc -total thesis/latex/chapters/04-konzept.tex

# Count all chapters
for f in thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex; do
    echo "$(basename $f): $(texcount -total -brief $f 2>/dev/null | grep -oP '\d+' | head -1) words"
done

When texcount is unavailable, fall back to a rough estimate:

# Rough word count (less accurate, includes some LaTeX commands)
cat thesis/latex/chapters/04-konzept.tex | \
    sed 's/\\[a-zA-Z]*\({[^}]*}\)*//g' | \
    sed 's/%.*//g' | \
    wc -w

TODO Markers

Scans .tex files for TODO markers in various formats:

# Standard TODO comments
grep -rn "% TODO" thesis/latex/chapters/

# TODO in citation placeholders
grep -rn "\\\\cite{TODO" thesis/latex/chapters/

# Inline TODO notes (if using todonotes package)
grep -rn "\\\\todo{" thesis/latex/chapters/
grep -rn "\\\\todo\[" thesis/latex/chapters/

# Missing content markers
grep -rn "\\\\missingfigure" thesis/latex/chapters/
grep -rn "FIXME" thesis/latex/chapters/

Uncited Claims

Identifies claims that should have citations but do not. Heuristic detection:

# Find sentences with strong claims but no \cite nearby
# (Heuristic: lines containing "zeigt", "beweist", "ist bekannt" without \cite)
grep -n "zeigt\|beweist\|ist bekannt\|wurde gezeigt\|laut Studien" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex | \
    grep -v "\\\\cite"

Also detects placeholder citations:

grep -rn "\\\\cite{TODO" thesis/latex/chapters/
grep -rn "\\\\cite{?}" thesis/latex/chapters/
grep -rn "\[QUELLE\]" thesis/latex/chapters/

Figure Count and References

# Count figures defined
grep -c "\\\\begin{figure}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex

# Count figure references
grep -oP "\\\\ref\{fig:[^}]+\}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex | sort -u | wc -l

# Find figures that are defined but never referenced
comm -23 \
    <(grep -oP "\\\\label\{fig:[^}]+\}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex thesis/latex/figures/*.tex | grep -oP "fig:[^}]+" | sort -u) \
    <(grep -oP "\\\\ref\{fig:[^}]+\}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex | grep -oP "fig:[^}]+" | sort -u)

Citation Count and Integrity

# Count unique citations used
grep -ohP "\\\\cite\{[^}]+\}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex | \
    tr ',' '\n' | grep -oP "[a-zA-Z0-9_-]+" | sort -u | wc -l

# Find citations used but not in .bib file
grep -ohP "\\\\cite\{[^}]+\}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex | \
    tr ',' '\n' | grep -oP "[a-zA-Z0-9_-]+" | sort -u | while read key; do
    grep -q "@.*{${key}," thesis/latex/bibliography/references.bib || echo "MISSING: $key"
done

# Find .bib entries never cited
grep -oP "@\w+\{([^,]+)," thesis/latex/bibliography/references.bib | \
    grep -oP "\{(.+)," | tr -d '{,' | while read key; do
    grep -rq "\\\\cite{.*${key}" thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex || echo "UNUSED: $key"
done

Progress Reports

Standard Report

Generated on demand, provides a snapshot of current progress.

=== Thesis Progress Report ===
Stand: 2026-02-22

Titel: Agentenbasierte KI-Systeme: Multi-Agent-Orchestrierung
       am Beispiel von juliaz_agents

Gesamtfortschritt: 8,400 / 25,000 Woerter (33.6%)
Deadline: 2026-04-30 (67 Tage verbleibend)

Kapitel                        Woerter   Ziel    %     Status
--------------------------------------------------------------
01 Einleitung                    1,200   3,000   40%   entwurf
02 Verwandte Arbeiten              800   3,000   27%   notizen
03 Grundlagen                    2,100   4,000   53%   entwurf
04 Konzept und Entwurf           2,500   5,000   50%   entwurf
05 Implementierung               1,800   5,000   36%   notizen
06 Evaluation                        0   3,000    0%   leer
07 Fazit und Ausblick                0   2,000    0%   leer

Offene Punkte:
- 12 TODO-Markierungen gesamt
- 5 unbelegte Behauptungen
- 3 fehlende Abbildungen
- 8 Zitate noch als Platzhalter

Naechste Prioritaeten:
1. Kapitel 06 (Evaluation) beginnen — noch leer
2. TODO-Markierungen in Kapitel 04 aufloesen (4 Stueck)
3. Fehlende Abbildungen in Kapitel 05 erstellen

Per-Chapter Detail Report

=== Kapitel 04: Konzept und Entwurf ===
Status: entwurf
Woerter: 2,500 / 5,000 (50%)
Letzte Aenderung: 2026-02-20

Abschnitte:
  [x] 4.1 Systemarchitektur
  [x] 4.2 Agentenrollen
  [ ] 4.3 Kommunikationsprotokoll
  [ ] 4.4 Skill-System
  [x] 4.5 Entwurfsentscheidungen

TODOs:
  Zeile 45: % TODO: MCP-Vergleich mit REST ergaenzen
  Zeile 78: % TODO: Diagramm Skill-Hierarchie einfuegen
  Zeile 112: \cite{TODO:langchain-comparison}
  Zeile 134: % TODO: Gegenargumente fuer Agent-Architektur

Abbildungen:
  [x] fig:systemarchitektur (referenziert Zeile 52)
  [x] fig:agentenrollen (referenziert Zeile 89)
  [ ] fig:skill-hierarchie (referenziert Zeile 80, aber nicht erstellt)
  [ ] fig:kommunikationsprotokoll (noch nicht referenziert)

Zitate: 8 verwendet, 1 Platzhalter

Warnings

The tracker generates warnings when it detects potential issues.

Inactivity Warning

WARNUNG: Kapitel 05 (Implementierung) wurde seit 7 Tagen nicht bearbeitet.
Status: notizen — noch kein Entwurf geschrieben.

Triggers when a chapter with status below "final" has not been modified in N days:

• leer: warn after 3 days
• notizen: warn after 5 days
• entwurf: warn after 7 days
• ueberarbeitet: warn after 14 days

Imbalance Warning

WARNUNG: Kapitel 04 (5,200 Woerter) ist deutlich laenger als Kapitel 06 (800 Woerter).
Verhaeltnis zum Ziel: 104% vs. 27%. Moegliche Unausgewogenheit.

Triggers when a chapter exceeds its target by more than 20% while another chapter is below 30%.

Deadline Warning

WARNUNG: 30 Tage bis Deadline. Aktueller Fortschritt: 52%.
Benoetigt: ~400 Woerter/Tag um das Ziel zu erreichen.
Kapitel 06 und 07 sind noch leer.

Calculates required daily word count to meet the deadline, factoring in current completion rate.

Empty Section Warning

WARNUNG: Folgende Abschnitte enthalten keinen Inhalt:
- 04-konzept, Section 4.3 (Kommunikationsprotokoll)
- 04-konzept, Section 4.4 (Skill-System)
- 06-evaluation, alle Abschnitte

Orphan Reference Warning

WARNUNG: 2 Abbildungen definiert aber nie referenziert:
- fig:bridge-detail (figures/fig-05-bridge-detail.tex)
- fig:timeline-v1 (figures/fig-05-timeline-v1.tex)

Citation Health Warning

WARNUNG: 3 Zitate in .bib aber nie verwendet:
- smith2024agents
- brown2023orchestration
- mueller2024thesis

5 Zitate verwendet aber fehlend in .bib:
- \cite{TODO:mcp-spec}
- \cite{TODO:openai-function-calling}
- \cite{langchain2024}
- \cite{autogen2024}
- \cite{dorri2018multiagent}

Update Workflow

After a Writing Session

1. Scan all .tex files for changes (compare modification dates)
2. Count words in each modified chapter
3. Detect new/resolved TODO markers
4. Update progress.json with new counts and timestamps
5. Check for warning conditions
6. Report changes since last update

# Quick update script concept:
for chapter in thesis/latex/chapters/*.tex; do
    name=$(basename "$chapter" .tex)
    words=$(texcount -total -brief "$chapter" 2>/dev/null | grep -oP '\d+' | head -1)
    todos=$(grep -c "TODO\|FIXME\|\\\\todo{" "$chapter" 2>/dev/null)
    modified=$(stat -f "%Sm" -t "%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%S" "$chapter" 2>/dev/null)
    echo "$name: $words words, $todos TODOs, modified $modified"
done

Automatic Status Inference

The tracker can infer chapter status from observable metrics:

• leer: word_count < 50
• notizen: word_count < (target * 0.3) AND contains TODO markers or bullet lists
• entwurf: word_count >= (target * 0.5) AND still has TODO markers
• ueberarbeitet: word_count >= (target * 0.8) AND TODO markers < 3
• final: word_count >= (target * 0.9) AND TODO markers == 0 AND uncited_claims == 0

These are heuristics. The actual status can be overridden manually.

Integration with Existing Documentation System

The thesis-tracker connects to the existing documentation infrastructure:

Session Buffer (thesis/memory/session_buffer.md)

• When the session buffer flushes (every 5 entries), the tracker checks if any thesis writing was done
• Maps session activities to chapter progress updates

Protocol Documents

• Uses chronological protocol dates to track the writing timeline
• Uses thematic protocol to verify that all major themes have corresponding chapter coverage

Git History

• Can compare progress.json across commits to see progress over time
• Tracks which chapters were modified in each commit

Markdown Summary Output

For quick overviews (e.g., in chat or documentation), generates a compact Markdown summary:

## Thesis Progress — 2026-02-22

| Kapitel | Woerter | Ziel | Fortschritt | Status |
|---------|---------|------|-------------|--------|
| 01 Einleitung | 1,200 | 3,000 | 40% | entwurf |
| 02 Verwandte Arbeiten | 800 | 3,000 | 27% | notizen |
| 03 Grundlagen | 2,100 | 4,000 | 53% | entwurf |
| 04 Konzept | 2,500 | 5,000 | 50% | entwurf |
| 05 Implementierung | 1,800 | 5,000 | 36% | notizen |
| 06 Evaluation | 0 | 3,000 | 0% | leer |
| 07 Fazit | 0 | 2,000 | 0% | leer |
| **Gesamt** | **8,400** | **25,000** | **33.6%** | |

**TODOs**: 12 | **Unbelegte Behauptungen**: 5 | **Deadline**: 67 Tage

Rate of Progress Tracking

Beyond snapshots, the tracker monitors writing velocity:

{
  "velocity": {
    "last_7_days": {
      "words_written": 2400,
      "words_per_day": 343,
      "chapters_touched": ["03-grundlagen", "04-konzept"],
      "todos_resolved": 4,
      "todos_added": 2
    },
    "projected_completion": "2026-04-15",
    "on_track": true
  }
}

This requires storing historical snapshots. The tracker saves a daily snapshot to thesis/progress-history/YYYY-MM-DD.json for trend analysis.

Quick Commands

Common operations the tracker supports:

• Status: Show full progress report
• Chapter N: Show detail report for a specific chapter
• Update: Rescan all files and refresh progress.json
• Warnings: Show all active warnings
• Velocity: Show writing speed and projected completion
• Compare: Compare current progress to N days ago
• Summary: Generate compact Markdown summary