Use this skill to challenge assumptions early and to audit outputs before external sharing.
Modes
- Critique mode: find weak assumptions, missing evidence, physical inconsistencies, and over-claimed interpretations.
- Audit mode: check reproducibility, internal consistency, citation support, and readiness for external sharing.
When To Use
- Reviewing a hypothesis, interpretation, or draft conclusion.
- Checking a manuscript section, proposal section, plot set, or methods summary.
- Stress-testing whether evidence supports the stated claim.
- Running a final pass before submission, export, or sharing outside the group.
- Draft claims, figures, tables, code summaries, or workflow descriptions.
- Proposal or manuscript text.
- Uncertainty statements, assumptions, and cited evidence.
Procedure