Review

Use this skill to challenge assumptions early and to audit outputs before external sharing.

Modes

1. Critique mode: find weak assumptions, missing evidence, physical inconsistencies, and over-claimed interpretations.
2. Audit mode: check reproducibility, internal consistency, citation support, and readiness for external sharing.

When To Use

1. Reviewing a hypothesis, interpretation, or draft conclusion.
2. Checking a manuscript section, proposal section, plot set, or methods summary.
3. Stress-testing whether evidence supports the stated claim.
4. Running a final pass before submission, export, or sharing outside the group.

Inputs

1. Draft claims, figures, tables, code summaries, or workflow descriptions.
2. Proposal or manuscript text.
3. Uncertainty statements, assumptions, and cited evidence.

Procedure