Target Journal

Step 3: Journal Recommendations (3 Tiers)

Tier 1: Reach Journals

• Top-5 general interest (if contribution warrants)
• For each: why it fits, recent similar publications, desk rejection risk

Tier 2: Strong Field Journals

• From domain-profile.md field journal list
• Match to paper's specific sub-field

Tier 3: Solid Alternatives

• JEEA, JAE, Economics Letters, specialized journals

Step 4: Formatting Requirements

For the top 3 recommended journals:

Step 5: Submission Checklist

Generate checklist for top journal choice:

• Manuscript formatting
• Cover letter (addressed to current editor)
• JEL codes and keywords
• Data availability statement
• Replication package
• Suggested/excluded referees

Step 6: Strategic Notes

• Desk rejection risk — honest assessment
• Suggested referees — 3-5 names with expertise match
• Timing considerations — deadlines, conference cycles
• Competing papers — recent working papers on same topic
• Resubmission strategy — if rejected from Tier 1, which Tier 2 journal next?

Step 7: Save and Present

Save to quality_reports/journal_targeting_[date].md

Principles

• Be honest about fit. Don't suggest AER for every paper.
• Domain-profile aware. Use the field-specific journal tiers, not generic lists.
• Recent publications matter. Check if the journal recently published on the topic.
• Don't over-optimize. The best journal is one that publishes the paper.
• Formatting details change. Flag any uncertain requirements.