5-stage intelligence critique pipeline. Multi-agent critique system for deep analysis, verification, and synthesis of research outputs.
5-stage intelligence critique pipeline. A multi-agent system designed for rigorous analysis, verification, and synthesis of research outputs through specialized critique agents.
┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐
│ Oct │────→│ Oct │────→│ Oct │────→│ Oct │────→│ Oct │
│ Portal │ │ Mine │ │ Judge │ │ Skeptic │ │ Weave │
└──────────┘ └──────────┘ └──────────┘ └──────────┘ └──────────┘
│ │ │ │ │
Receipt Extraction Prioritization Verification Synthesis
│ │ │ │ │
Ingest Pull out Rank by Fact-check Weave
content insights importance & validate final
output
# Run complete 5-stage critique on research output
critique_result = await run_critique_pipeline(
content=research_output,
depth="comprehensive", # or "quick", "standard"
focus_areas=["factual_accuracy", "logical_consistency", "source_quality"]
)
# Run specific stage only
portal_result = await oct_portal.ingest(content)
mine_result = await oct_mine.extract(portal_result)
judge_result = await oct_judge.prioritize(mine_result)
skeptic_result = await oct_skeptic.verify(judge_result)
weave_result = await oct_weave.synthesize(skeptic_result)
# Full pipeline critique
openclaw critique --input research.md --output critique.md
# Quick critique (stages 1, 4, 5 only)
openclaw critique --input research.md --mode quick
# Deep critique (all stages with recursion)
openclaw critique --input research.md --mode deep --recursive
| Agent | Tier | Role | Primary Model |
|---|---|---|---|
| OctPortal | T3 | Receipt & Routing | ilmu-mini-free-v2 |
| OctMine | T2 | Extraction | claude-sonnet-4 |
| OctJudge | T2 | Prioritization | claude-sonnet-4 |
| OctSkeptic | T2 | Verification | claude-sonnet-4 |
| OctWeave | T2 | Synthesis | claude-sonnet-4 |
# Critique Report: [Subject]
## Executive Summary
[High-level findings in 2-3 sentences]
## Critical Findings
1. **[Severity]** Finding description
- Evidence: [source]
- Impact: [consequence]
- Recommendation: [action]
## Verified Claims
- ✅ [Claim with strong evidence]
- ⚠️ [Claim with partial evidence]
## Red Flags
- 🚩 [Critical issue requiring attention]
## Recommendations
1. [Priority 1 recommendation]
2. [Priority 2 recommendation]
## Confidence Score: [X.X]/5.0
{
"octoberxinCritique": {
"enabled": true,
"defaultDepth": "standard",
"recursiveVerification": false,
"parallelStages": ["OctMine", "OctJudge"],
"minConfidenceThreshold": 3.0,
"logToMemory": true,
"generateDiff": true
}
}