Review Swarm

Each agent should:

• Read paper/qcml_geometric_sde.tex and paper/references.bib
• Load canonical JSON: experiments/outputs/regime_detection/causal_comparison_20260303_231013.json
• Score 7 dimensions (novelty, soundness, clarity, significance, reproducibility, presentation, ethics) on 1-5 scale
• Spot-check 5+ numbers from paper against source JSON
• Classify findings as CRITICAL / MAJOR / MINOR
• Give overall recommendation (Strong Accept through Reject)

After all 4 complete, synthesize:

• Average scores across reviewers
• Prioritized action list (CRITICAL > MAJOR > MINOR)
• Disagreements between reviewers
• Overall submission readiness assessment

Prompt Files

Located at paper/review/prompts/reviewer_{statistician,physicist,quant,hostile}.md

Output

Reviews saved to paper/review/reviews/review_YYYYMMDD_PERSPECTIVE.md Synthesis saved to paper/review/reviews/synthesis_YYYYMMDD.md