Use when deciding the fate of a defeated general who returns after losing their forces. Convenes advisors, weighs strict versus lenient views, and defers to higher authority rather than unilateral execution.
A structured decision-making procedure for handling defeated generals who return to camp after losing their forces. Based on Wei Qing's handling of General Su Jian.
Receive the Returning Officer
Convene a Council of Advisors
Hear Competing Arguments
Consider Key Factors
Defer to Higher Authority
"不患无威" - A true leader need not worry about lacking authority; executing subordinates to demonstrate power is unnecessary and may undermine trust.
The sovereign makes the final decision, preserving chain of command while allowing for mercy or justice as appropriate.